Rating of Health Plan

Respondents were asked to give their health plan an overall rating, with 0 equaling “worst health plan possible” and 10 equaling “best health plan possible.” The tables below represent the percentage of respondents who rated their health plan 8, 9 or 10.

HEALTH CARE RATING OF 8, 9 OR 10
Commercial Medicaid Medicare
Year HMO PPO HMO HMO PPO
2017 63.6 60.3 77 - -
2016 63.4 59.4 75.9 - -
2015 64.1 59.5 75.0 86.4 86.1
2014 66.1 59.7 75.1 86.5 86.3
2013 67.6 60.3 74.7 87.8 87.7
2012 65.3 57.9 73.5 88.3 87.9
2011 66.1 58.4 73.5 88.5 87.7
2010 64.2 58.6 72.4 87.5 86.6
2009 62.7 57.3 70.7 84.4 81.9
2008 64.3 59.7 72.7 85.5 83.8
2007 61.9 56.8 70.7 85.9 82.6
2006 63.0 59.5 70.1 86.7 84.1
2005 65.2 67.1 71.9 87.7 84.2
2004 64.1 - 71.2 85.2 -
2003 61.8 - 69.9 81.4 -
2002 61.3 - 69.3 85.9 -
2001 61.8 - 51.4 86.6 -
2000 59.3 - - - -
HEALTH CARE RATING OF 9 OR 10
Commercial Medicaid Medicare
Year HMO PPO HMO HMO PPO
2017 40.7 36.3 60.1 64.3 59.5
2016 40.4 35.2 59.0 62.9 58.8
2015 40.2 34.7 57.7 60.8 55.0
2014 42.1 34.9 57.9 60.5 55.5
2013 44.8 36.0 57.4 62.8 58.6
2012 41.4 33.3 56.3 63.7 59.1
2011 42.1 33.9 55.6 63.9 58.5
2010 40.3 33.7 54.7 62.7 56.9
2009 38.3 32.4 52.5 59.0 52.2
2008 39.1 34.2 55.3 60.7 53.4
2007 37.1 31.8 53.3 61.1 52.9
2006 38.0 35.9 52.4 61.7 53.9
2005 39.8 43.1 54.0 61.3 54.2
2004 38.4 - 52.3 57.5 -
2003 36.7 - 51.7 53.3 -
2002 36.0 - 51.5 60.5 -
2001 37.4 - 69.1 62.4 -
2000 34.7 - - - -
1999 32.6 - - - -
  • Save

    Save your favorite pages and receive notifications whenever they’re updated.

    You will be prompted to log in to your NCQA account.

  • Email

    Share this page with a friend or colleague by Email.

    We do not share your information with third parties.

  • Print

    Print this page.